Infants, Teens More Likely to Reenter Foster Care, Study Finds

Infants, Teens More Likely to Reenter Foster Care, Study Finds

Children who are discharged from foster care as infants or in their early teens, or who have been in group placements, are more likely to reenter the foster care system than others, a study by the Center for State Child Welfare Data finds.

Funded by the Annie E. Casey Foundation and based on a sample of more than six hundred thousand children in twenty states who left foster care for the first time between 2003 and 2010, the report, Reentry to Foster Care: Identifying Candidates Under the Family First Act (27 pages, PDF), found that 27 percent of those reunified with their families and 17 percent of those placed with guardians had reentered the system as of the end of 2017. According to the study, the younger the age at exit, the higher the reentry rate — from 36 percent for infants under a year old to 16 percent for those between the ages of 15 and 17. The risk of reentry initially was greater for children who returned to their families than for those placed with guardians, and in both cases the risk was highest soon after discharge and declined sharply over four years. At the same time, the risk of reentry increased when former foster children, especially those placed with guardians, became teenagers, regardless of their age at exit, with rates peaking for 14- and 15-year-olds.

The study also found that children who had been in group placements (22 percent) or a foster family (21 percent) had a higher reentry rate than those who had received kinship care (16 percent) before being placed with a guardian. In addition, children from counties that were moderately socioeconomically disadvantaged had higher reentry rates than those from counties considered highly disadvantaged. In terms of race/ethnicity, white children who left foster care at age 11 or younger were more likely to return to care than African-American or Latinx children, while for children age 12 and up and among all children discharged to guardians reentry rates were highest among African Americans.

The report's authors recommend that state and local child welfare agencies focus on two groups — very young children and older youth, including those who have been discharged from care many years earlier — that could benefit substantially from the preventive services funded by the Family First Prevention Services Act.

"When a child has left foster care to live with family, the last thing we want is for them to need to return," said Rodney Brittingham, associate director of the Casey Foundation's Child Welfare Strategy Group. "As states develop their plans for taking advantage of Family First, this research can help child welfare agencies focus on families and young people who can benefit the most from services that help them stay together."

"Reentry to Foster Care: Identifying Candidates Under the Family First Act." Center for State Child Welfare Data Report 01/09/2020. "Infants and Teens More Likely to Experience Foster Care Reentry." Annie E. Casey Foundation Press Release 01/09/2020.